
Siemens 1.3 MW: 84 % less varnish in the gear oil while the turbine kept running
The gear oil in a 1.3 MW Siemens turbine had heavy fine-particle contamination, 201 ppm water and a high varnish level. After just over a year of offline filtration in service, particles above 4 µm were down 98.4 %, water down 68 % and I-MPC down 84 %.
ISO 4406 cleanliness code
The oil analysis from 11 January 2024 showed that the gear oil in a 1.3 MW Siemens turbine was in poor condition. There were 18,991 particles above 4 µm per ml, the cleanliness code was ISO 21/18/11, water was 201 ppm, and the varnish measurement gave I-MPC 23.2 and S-MPC 21.8. Viscosity at 40 °C was 296 cSt and was flagged for continued monitoring. The laboratory also saw signs that the oil might have been accidentally mixed with hydraulic oil, but this was not confirmed.
A wall-mounted DX1001-W unit ran the oil through the cartridge in a kidney loop while the turbine was in service. A new sample was taken on 27 March 2025 and analysed for particles, water (Karl Fischer), viscosity, acid number, MPC and ferrography.
The cleanliness code had improved to 15/14/11. Particles above 4 µm were down 98.4 % and particles above 6 µm down 92.5 %, while particles above 14 µm stayed stable at 13 to 14 per ml. Water was down 68 % to 65 ppm, I-MPC down 84 % to 3.6, S-MPC down 50 % and MPC weight down 75 %. Ferrography at 100 times magnification showed far fewer wear and varnish particles than the year before.
The sampling point sits upstream of the cartridge. Varnish released from internal surfaces during cleaning can therefore show up temporarily in the samples.
The figures before and after
| Measurement | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| ISO 4406 cleanliness code | 21/18/11 | 15/14/11 |
| Particles above 4 µm per ml | 18,991 | 299 |
| Particles above 6 µm per ml | 1,510 | 114 |
| Water, Karl Fischer (ppm) | 201 | 65 |
| I-MPC (insoluble varnish) | 23.2 | 3.6 |
| S-MPC (soluble varnish) | 21.8 | 10.9 |
| MPC weight (g) | 0.0108 | 0.0027 |
Read the full case study
The rest of the case study, with every before and after measurement, opens once you have entered your work email and company. You only need to do this once; then every case study on the site is open.
We only use the details to see which companies are reading. You will not receive newsletters, and we will not call you.