
Independent laboratory: the filtration does not remove the engine oil additives
Does fine filtration down to 0.1 µm remove the additives that protect the engine? POLARIS Laboratories followed the oil in a Jenbacher J316 on landfill gas with 14 samples over 8 weeks. Base number and acid number followed normal degradation, and there was no sign that the additives were being removed.
Base number, BN (first and last sample)
Gas engine oil contains additives that neutralise the acids formed in the crankcase. The amount is measured as base number (BN). When the base number falls below the engine manufacturer’s limit, the oil must be changed. An obvious question with filtration down to 0.1 µm is therefore whether the cartridge also takes out the additives.
POLARIS Laboratories, an independent oil laboratory, examined this on a Jenbacher J316 gas engine on landfill gas with Delta Xero filtration. The oil was an SAE 40 gas engine oil with a base number of about 4.5 when new. From 2 December 2020 to 25 January 2021, 14 samples were taken and analysed for base number, acid number, pH and oxidation.
The base number ranged from 2.7 to 5.2 and the acid number from 1.08 to 2.88, with the fluctuations that are normal for oil in service. Oxidation was stable at 7 to 8.
The laboratory’s conclusion is based on the thousands of landfill gas engine oils it analyses each year: there is no abnormal trend. If the filtration removed the additives, the base number would fall much faster and the acid number would rise sharply. That did not happen.
The figures before and after
| Measurement | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Base number, BN (first and last sample) | 3.1 | 3.8 |
| Acid number, AN (first and last sample) | 2.88 | 2.05 |
| pH (first and last sample) | 5.3 | 6.1 |
| Oxidation (first and last sample) | 8 | 7 |
| Base number across all 14 samples | lowest 2.7 | highest 5.2 |
Read the full case study
The rest of the case study, with every before and after measurement, opens once you have entered your work email and company. You only need to do this once; then every case study on the site is open.
We only use the details to see which companies are reading. You will not receive newsletters, and we will not call you.