
1.5 MW wind turbine: 3.8 kg of debris in one cartridge in 11 months
What is inside a used cartridge? Oil was pressed out of DXO cartridges from two identical gearboxes at the same wind farm. The first cartridge had collected 3.8 kg of debris in 11 months. In a gearbox that had already had its first cartridge changed, iron in the debris had fallen from 112 to 8.
Iron in the cartridge debris
A used cartridge shows what has been removed from the oil. DXO cartridges from DX1001-W units on the gearboxes of 1.5 MW wind turbines running on synthetic gear oil, ISO VG 320, were therefore analysed. The oil was pressed out of the cartridges and examined by membrane patch at 100 times magnification.
The first cartridge had been in service for 11 months. It contained about 3.8 kg of debris. Iron in the debris measured 112, the PQ index 102 and water 512 ppm. The varnish level was too high to register. The membrane patch was almost black with fibres and abrasive particles.
For comparison, a cartridge from a gearbox of the same type and age at the same wind farm was also analysed. Here it was the second cartridge. The first had been changed after only 4 months because it was full, with more than 4 kg of debris. The second cartridge had also been in service for about 11 months and contained 3.7 kg, but iron was now down to 8, the PQ index to 21 and water to 328 ppm. The membrane patch was much lighter.
The explanation is that the oil becomes clean enough to dissolve sludge and varnish from the gearbox surfaces again, and the cartridge then captures it. The varnish level in the second cartridge was still too high to register, even though the oil runs at 80 °C and above.
Note: the two cartridges come from two different gearboxes, not from the same gearbox over time.
The figures before and after
| Measurement | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Iron in the cartridge debris | 112 | 8 |
| PQ index (magnetic wear particles) | 102 | 21 |
| Water in the oil from the cartridge (ppm) | 512 | 328 |
| Debris in the cartridge after about 11 months (kg) | 3.8 | 3.7 |
Read the full case study
The rest of the case study, with every before and after measurement, opens once you have entered your work email and company. You only need to do this once; then every case study on the site is open.
We only use the details to see which companies are reading. You will not receive newsletters, and we will not call you.